Emotional influence in social media
Online communication can be seen as a large-scale social experiment that constantly provides us with data about users' activities, interactions and emotions. While their online behavior on the "micro" level is largely governed by individual traits, we find on the "macro" level remarkable statistical regularities. These can be reproduced by means of stochastic agent-based models that capture the non-linear response to emotional information in different online communities. This research opens a vast field to combine big data analysis, nonlinear dynamics, and statistical physics.
Selected Publications
Emotions and Activity Profiles of Influential Users in Product Reviews Communities
|
[2015]
|
Tanase, Dorian;
Garcia, David;
Garas, Antonios;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
Frontiers in Physics,
volume: 3,
number: 87
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
Viral marketing seeks to maximize the spread of a campaign
through an online social network, often targeting influential nodes with high
centrality. In this article, we analyze behavioral aspects of influential
users in trust-based product reviews communities, quantifying emotional
expression, helpfulness, and user activity level. We focus on two independent
product review communities, Dooyoo and Epinions, in which
users can write product reviews and define trust links to filter product
recommendations. Following the patterns of social contagion processes, we
measure user social influence by means of the k-shell decomposition of trust
networks. For each of these users, we apply sentiment analysis to extract
their extent of positive, negative, and neutral emotional expression. In
addition, we quantify the level of feedback they received in their reviews,
the length of their contributions, and their level of activity over their
lifetime in the community. We find that users of both communities exhibit a
large heterogeneity of social influence, and that helpfulness votes and age
are significantly better predictors of the influence of an individual than
sentiment. The most active of the analyzed communities shows a particular
structure, in which the inner core of users is qualitatively different from
its periphery in terms of a stronger positive and negative emotional
expression. These results suggest that both objective and subjective aspects
of reviews are relevant to the communication of subjective experience.
Sentiment cascades in the 15M movement
|
[2015]
|
Alvarez, Raquel;
Garcia, David;
Moreno, Yamir;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
EPJ Data Science,
volume: 4,
number: 6
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
Recent grassroots movements have suggested that online social networks might play a key role in their organization, as adherents have a fast, many-to-many, communication channel to help coordinate their mobilization. The structure and dynamics of the networks constructed from the digital traces of protesters have been analyzed to some extent recently. However, less effort has been devoted to the analysis of the semantic content of messages exchanged during the protest. Using the data obtained from a microblogging service during the brewing and active phases of the 15M movement in Spain, we perform the first large scale test of theories on collective emotions and social interaction in collective actions. Our findings show that activity and information cascades in the movement are larger in the presence of negative collective emotions and when users express themselves in terms related to social content. At the level of individual participants, our results show that their social integration in the movement, as measured through social network metrics, increases with their level of engagement and of expression of negativity. Our findings show that non-rational factors play a role in the formation and activity of social movements through online media, having important consequences for viral spreading.
Modeling collective emotions in online social systems
|
[2014]
|
Garcia, David;
Garas, Antonios;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
Collective Emotions
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
Every day, millions of Internet users leave online traces that are publicly accessible. Data
about forum comments, video downloads, or product reviews provide a valuable insight
into human online behavior. The retrieval of datasets of unprecedented size may eventu-
ally also allow testing of hypotheses or validation of theories that have been developed in
the social sciences, for example, about preferences, social influence (Lorenz, 2009; Onnela
& Reed-Tsochas, 2010), trust, and cooperation (Walter, Battiston, Yildirim, & Schweitzer,
2011). This recent scientific development has led to the emerging field of computational
social science (Lazer et al., 2009) which combines methods and tools from different tech-
nical and social disciplines. Also, psychology can benefit from this development by get-
ting access to data without designing expensive experimental setups of limited size. For
example, the analysis of Twitter messages allows studying the influence of the circadian
cycles on human mood (Golder & Macy, 2011), and sentiment analysis of large-scale
datasets reveals patterns of emotional expression predicted by earlier theories (Garcia,
Garas, & Schweitzer, 2012).
Damping sentiment analysis in online communication: Discussions, monologs and dialogs
|
[2013]
|
Thelwall, Mike;
Buckley, Kevan;
Paltoglou, George;
Skowron, Marcin;
Garcia, David;
Gobron, Stephane;
Ahn, Junghyun;
Kappas, Arvid;
Kuster, Dennis;
Janusz, A
|
In Proceedings of the 14th international conference on Computational Linguistics and Intelligent Text Processing
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
Sentiment analysis programs are now sometimes used to detect patterns of sentiment use over time in online communication and to help automated systems interact better with users. Nevertheless, it seems that no previouspublished study has assessed whether the position of individual texts within ongoing communication can be exploited to help detect their sentiments. This article assesses apparent sentiment anomalies in on-going communication – textsassigned significantly different sentiment strength to the average of previoustexts – to see whether their classification can be improved. The results suggestthat a damping procedure to reduce sudden large changes in sentiment can improve classification accuracy but that the optimal procedure will depend on thetype of texts processed.
The Role of Emotions in Contributors Activity: A Case Study of the Gentoo Community
|
[2013]
|
Garcia, David;
Zanetti, Marcelo Serrano;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
In Proceedings of the International Conference on Social Computing and Its Applications
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
We analyse the relation between the emotions and the activity of contributors in the Open Source Software project Gentoo. Our case study builds on extensive data sets from the project's bug tracking platform Bugzilla, to quantify the activity of contributors, and its mail archives, to quantify the emotions of contributors by means of sentiment analysis. The Gentoo project is known for a considerable drop in development performance after the sudden retirement of a central contributor. We analyse how this event correlates with the negative emotions, both in bilateral email discussions with the central contributor, and at the level of the whole community of contributors. We then extend our study to consider the activity patters on Gentoo contributors in general. We find that contributors are more likely to become inactive when they express strong positive or negative emotions in the bug tracker, or when they deviate from the expected value of emotions in the mailing list. We use these insights to develop a Bayesian classifier that detects the risk of contributors leaving the project. Our analysis opens new perspectives for measuring online contributor motivation by means of sentiment analysis and for real-time predictions of contributor turnover in Open Source Software projects.
The rise and fall of a central contributor: Dynamics of social organization and performance in the Gentoo community
|
[2013]
|
Zanetti, Marcelo Serrano;
Scholtes, Ingo;
Tessone, Claudio Juan;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
CHASE/ICSE '13 Proceedings of the 6th International Workshop on Cooperative and Human Aspects of Software Engineering
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
Social organization and division of labor crucially influence the performance of collaborative software engineering efforts. In this paper, we provide a quantitative analysis of the relation between social organization and performance in Gentoo, an Open Source community developing a Linux distribution. We study the structure and dynamics of collaborations as recorded in the project's bug tracking system over a period of ten years. We identify a period of increasing centralization after which most interactions in the community were mediated by a single central contributor. In this period of maximum centralization, the central contributor unexpectedly left the project, thus posing a significant challenge for the community. We quantify how the rise, the activity as well as the subsequent sudden dropout of this central contributor affected both the social organization and the bug handling performance of the Gentoo community. We analyze social organization from the perspective of network theory and augment our quantitative findings by interviews with prominent members of the Gentoo community which shared their personal insights.
Dyads to Groups : Modeling Interactions with Affective Dialog Systems
|
[2013]
|
Rank, Stefan;
Skowron, Marcin;
Garcia, David
|
International Journal of Computational Linguistics Research,
pages: 22-32,
volume: 4,
number: 1
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
Affect Listeners are applied as tools for studying the role of emotions in online communication. They need to interact both in dyads as well as in group settings with multiple users. In this paper, we present the evolution of such affective dialog systems from a focus on dyadic interaction to multi-party interaction on chat networks. Starting from experiments on the use of these dialog systems in virtual dyadic settings, we outline the requirements, design and implementation decisions necessary to apply the systems to affective interactions with multiple users. Finally, we introduce two realisations of Interactive Affective Bots designed for such interaction scenarios that integrate modelling of individuals and groups as part of their decision mechanism.
Political alignment and emotional expression in Spanish Tweets
|
[2013]
|
Garcia, David;
Thelwall, Mike
|
Workshop on Sentiment Analysis at SEPLN
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
We present a study political discourse and emotional expression through
a dataset of Spanish tweets. We analyze the political position of four major parties
through their Twitter activity, revealing that Twitter political discourse depends
on subjective perception, and resembles the political space of Spain. We propose
a simplified lexicon-based method to identify the topics of a tweet, which works
especially well to detect the political content of tweets. Furthermore, we adapted
SentiStrength to Spanish, by translating and converting an established lexicon of
word valence. Under certain design decisions, this tool performs better than random,
with ample room for improvement. Finally, we combined three datasets to analyze
the sentiment expressed in the political tweets of four major Spanish parties, finding
differences related to the status quo, and the Spanish political climate.
Political polarization and popularity in online participatory media : An integrated approach
|
[2012]
|
Garcia, David;
Mendez, Fernando;
Serdult, Uwe;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
In Proceedings of the Proceedings of the first edition workshop on Politics, elections and data - PLEAD '12
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
We present our approach to online popularity and its applications to political science, aiming at the creation of agentbased models that reproduce patterns of popularity in participatory media. We illustrate our approach analyzing a dataset from Youtube, composed of the view statistics and
comments for the videos of the U.S. presidential campaigns of 2008 and 2012. Using sentiment analysis, we quantify the collective emotions expressed by the viewers, finding that democrat campaigns elicited more positive collective emotions than republican campaigns. Techniques from computational social science allow us to measure virality of the videos of each campaign, to find that democrat videos are shared faster but republican ones are remembered longer inside the community. Last we present our work in progress in voting advice applications, and our results analyzing the
data from choose4greece.com. We show how we assess the policy differences between parties and their voters, and how voting advice applications can be extended to test our agentbased models.
Emotional divergence influences information spreading in Twitter
|
[2012]
|
Pfitzner, Rene;
Garas, Antonios;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
In Proceedings of the 6th International AAAI Conference on Weblogs and Social Media
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
We analyze data about the micro-blogging site Twitter using sentiment extraction techniques. From an information per- spective, Twitter users are involved mostly in two processes: information creation and subsequent distribution (tweeting), and pure information distribution (retweeting), with pro- nounced preference to the first. However a rather substantial fraction of tweets are retweeted. Here, we address the role of the sentiment expressed in tweets for their potential after- math. We find that although the overall sentiment (polarity) does not influence the probability of a tweet to be retweeted, a new measure called emotional divergence does have an im- pact. In general, tweets with high emotional diversity have a better chance of being retweeted, hence influencing the dis- tribution of information.
Positive words carry less information than negative words
|
[2012]
|
Garcia, David;
Garas, Antonios;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
EPJ Data Science,
pages: 3,
volume: 1
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
We show that the frequency of word use is not only determined by the word length [1] and the average information content [2], but also by its emotional content.We have analysed three established lexica of affective word usage in English, German, and Spanish, to verify that these lexica have a neutral, unbiased, emotional content. Taking into account the frequency of word usage, we find that words with a positive emotional content are more frequently used. This lends support to Pollyanna hypothesis [3] that there should be a positive bias in human expression. We also find that negative words contain more information than positive words, as the informativeness of a word increases uniformly with its valence decrease. Our findings support earlier conjectures about (i) the relation between word frequency and information content, and (ii) the impact of positive emotions on communication and social links.
Emotional persistence in online chatting communities
|
[2012]
|
Garas, Antonios;
Garcia, David;
Skowron, Marcin;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
Scientific Reports,
pages: 402,
volume: 2
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
How do users behave in online chatrooms, where they instantaneously read and write posts? We analyzed about 2.5 million posts covering various topics in Internet relay channels, and found that user activity patterns follow known power-law and stretched exponential distributions, indicating that online chat activity is not different from other forms of communication. Analysing the emotional expressions (positive, negative, neutral) of users, we revealed a remarkable persistence both for individual users and channels. I.e. despite their anonymity, users tend to follow social norms in repeated interactions in online chats, which results in a specific emotional “tone” of the channels. We provide an agent-based model of emotional interaction, which recovers qualitatively both the activity patterns in chatrooms and the emotional persistence of users and channels. While our assumptions about agent's emotional expressions are rooted in psychology, the model allows to test different hypothesis regarding their emotional impact in online communication.
An event-based architecture to manage virtual human non-verbal communication in 3d chatting environment
|
[2012]
|
Gobron, Stephane;
Ahn, Junghyun;
Garcia, David;
Silvestre, Quentin;
Thalmann, Daniel;
Boulic, Ronan
|
Proceedings of the VII Conference on Articulated Motion and Deformable Objects 2012
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
Non-verbal communication (NVC) makes up about two-thirds of all communication between two people or between one speaker and a group of listeners. However, this fundamental aspect of communicating is mostly omitted in 3D social forums or virtual world oriented games. This paper proposes an answer by presenting a multi-user 3D-chatting system enriched with NVC relative to motion. This event-based architecture tries to recreate a context by extracting emotional cues from dialogs and derives virtual human potential body expressions from that event triggered context model. We structure the paper by expounding the system architecture enabling the modeling NVC in a multi-user 3D-chatting environment. There, we present the transition from dialog-based emotional cues to body language, and the management of NVC events in the context of a virtual reality client-server system. Finally, we illustrate the results with graphical scenes and a statistical analysis representing the increase of events due to NVC.
An nvc emotional model for conversational virtual humans in a 3d chatting environment
|
[2012]
|
Ahn, Junghyun;
Gobron, Stephane;
Garcia, David;
Silvestre, Quentin;
Thalmann, Daniel;
Bulic, Ronan
|
Proceedings of the VII Conference on Articulated Motion and Deformable Objects 2012
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
This paper proposes a new emotional model for Virtual Humans (VHs) in a conversational environment. As a part of a multi-users emotional 3D-chatting system, this paper focus on how to formulate and visualize the flow of emotional state defined by the Valence-ArousalDominance (VAD) parameters. From this flow of emotion over time, we successfully visualized the change of VHs’ emotional state through the proposed emoFaces and emoMotions. The notion of Non-Verbal Communication (NVC) was exploited for driving plausible emotional expressions during conversation. With the help of a proposed interface, where a user can parameterize emotional state and flow, we succeeded to vary the emotional expressions and reactions of VHs in a 3D conversation scene.
Effects of social influence on the wisdom of crowds
|
[2012]
|
Mavrodiev, Pavlin;
Tessone, Claudio Juan;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
In Proceedings of the conference on Collective Intelligence 2012
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
Wisdom of crowds refers to the phenomenon that the aggregate prediction or forecast of a group of individuals can be surprisingly more accurate than most individuals in the group, and sometimes - than any of the individuals comprising it. This article models the impact of social influence on the wisdom of crowds. We build a minimalistic representation of individuals as Brownian particles coupled by means of social influence. We demonstrate that the model can reproduce results of a previous empirical study. This allows us to draw more fundamental conclusions about the role of social influence: In particular, we show that the question of whether social influence has a positive or negative net effect on the wisdom of crowds is ill-defined. Instead, it is the starting configuration of the population, in terms of its diversity and accuracy, that directly determines how beneficial social influence actually is. The article further examines the scenarios under which social influence promotes or impairs the wisdom of crowds.
Emotions in product reviews – empirics and models
|
[2011]
|
Garcia, David;
Schweitzer, Frank
|
Proceedings of 2011 IEEE International Conference on Privacy, Security, Risk, and Trust, and IEEE International Conference on Social Computing, PASSAT/SocialCom
pages: 483--488
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
Online communities provide Internet users with means to overcome some information barriers and constraints, such as the difficulty to gather independent information about products and firms. Product review communities allow customers to share their opinions and emotions after the purchase of a product. We introduce a new dataset of product reviews from Amazon.com, with emotional information extracted by sentiment detection tools. Our statistical analysis of this data provides evidence for the existence of polemic reviews, as well as for the coexistence of positive and negative emotions inside reviews. We find a strong bias towards large values in the expression of positive emotions, while negative ones are more evenly distributed. We identified different time dynamics of the creation of reviews dependent on the presence of marketing and word of mouth effects. We define an agent-based model of the users of product review communities using a modeling framework for online emotions. This model can reproduce the scenarios of response to external influences, as well as some properties of the distributions of positive and negative emotions expressed in product reviews. This analysis and model can provide guidelines to manufacturers on how to increase customer satisfaction and how to measure the emotional impact of marketing campaigns through reviews data.
An agent-based model of collective emotions in online communities
|
[2010]
|
Schweitzer, Frank;
Garcia, David
|
The European Physical Journal B,
pages: 533-545,
volume: 77,
number: 4
|
more» «less
|
Abstract
We develop an agent-based framework to model the emergence of collective emotions, which is applied to online communities. Agent’s individual emotions are described by their valence and arousal. Using the concept of Brownian agents, these variables change according to a stochastic dynamics, which also considers the feedback from online communication. Agents generate emotional information, which is stored and distributed in a field modeling the online medium. This field affects the emotional states of agents in a non-linearmanner.We derive conditions for the emergence of collective emotions, observable in a bimodal valence distribution. Dependent on a saturated or a superlinear feedback between the information field and the agent’s arousal, we further identify scenarios where collective emotions only appear once or in a repeated manner. The analytical results are illustrated by agent-based computer simulations. Our framework provides testable hypotheses about the emergence of collective emotions, which can be verified by data from online communities.
|